Director: Enki Bilal
Screenplay: Enki Bilal and Serge Lehman
Based on the comics La
Foire aux immortels and La Femme piège by Enki
Bilal
Cast: Linda Hardy as Jill;
Thomas Kretschmann as Nikopol; Charlotte Rampling as Elma Turner; Yann Collette
as Froebe; Frédéric Pierrot as John; Thomas M. Pollard as Horus; Joe Sheridan
as Allgood; Corinne Jaber as Lily Liang
Ephemeral Waves
What the hell, it's a naked guy with a bird's head!
Immortal is a difficult movie to deal with. For the most part, this
is actually catnip even with its weird creative decisions for me, the creation
of Enki Bilal, a Yugoslav emigrant to
France and comic book artist who, alongside his prolificness, was making films
before Immortal already. In terms of
a set-up, Immortal is clearly
indebted to a world of science fiction, let alone The Fifth Element (1997), alongside Bilal's own work, which if you see stands out exceptionally. The
film, a complex mess to unravel, had enough in terms of a bizarre scenario to
stand out but also has too many things to factor in why this is a difficult
film to recommend.
Staying with the good, this is 3095
in New York City. A giant floating Egyptian pyramid is inecplicably floating
above in the skyline. The trope of a dystopia of corrupt corporations, here
literally a medical group called Eugenic, exists, this one partaking in illegal
medical experiments. There are non-humans, deemed dangerous, stuck in Level 3,
where humans are warned to avoid, whilst Central Park has become an
"Intrusion Zone", a frozen winter environment where people attempting
to enter usually die, spat out as bones when they attempt to enter, and
penguins are wandering about for no reason. In terms of world building, Bilal's eye is deliciously weird. Science
fiction, I will be honest, is more interest if vivid in world building and/or
bizarre. Here a side character, the most beloved for me called Willie, sets up
how idiosyncratic this can be as they are a sentient phantom dispenser in a
hotel bathroom, one who can provide a handgun as he can, in his cute way,
toothpaste from a wall he is stuck to.
In seriousness as well, even the clichéd
bleak dystopia of flying cars and artificially generated lungs made in China is
not an issue, as it feels immersive, allowing for the stranger details to contrast,
the bleak grey and CGi created world a prop to allow the more idiosyncratic
content to stand out. That the Egyptian God Horus has to sire a child in seven
days, entering the human world, to keep his immortality, which becomes the main
crux of the narrative; that a mysterious blue haired woman named Jill exists
who is completely alien in form, who weeps blue tears that can even fill a
bathtub; that flying monstrous hammerhead sharks, blood red, exist as a species
that once were a threat, here appearing as a humanoid one and the regular
flying variety.
Here we get to the first
immediate issue with Immortal however,
even if for me this is not an issue, as it is an aesthetic concept other
viewers would not be tolerant on. This probably should have been animated - it
almost already is. Most of the side cast, including major characters like the
corrupt senator Allgood, are digitally animated models. The main cast however
are real actors. Jill as played by Linda Hardy. Horus' final host, after
causing seven to explode when their bodies are too sick or full of implants to
host him, is Nikopol, a man whose influence is responsible for the anti-Eugenic
holographic signs appearing everywhere in the city, abruptly woken from his cryogenic
imprisonment when the tub falls from the sky, played by German actor Thomas Kretschmann. The legendary
British actress Charlotte Rampling
plays Elma Turner, a doctor who becomes fascinated with Jill and takes her in
from the police; made to wear an unfortunate headpiece, she can nonetheless act
her way around it.

The contrast to almost everyone
else being animated, and with a limited budget despite the ambition, is strange
but I can still appreciate its curious mishmash of content. Where the issues
come around, which I and other viewers will agree is problematic, is the plot.
Specifically in regards to Horus' goal first. Alongside the ultimate reveal
that this is a plot never properly told, Jill for obvious reasons is a unique
entity who cries blue tears and exists from another dimension, becoming more
and more human but of an unnatural form which makes her ideal for Horus's plans.
Obviously, Horus' goal is problematic, to want to conceive a child quickly, in
that we are dealing with rape as a subject. You would presume the idea is that,
near death originally missing a leg from his awakening, Nikopol is stuck in an
unfortunate situation of playing host to an entity, like Gods in mythology, who
has no concept of modern morality. This is still morally dicey, but it is a
premise you can tell in how, if you dealt with it right, this is about of gods
involving themselves in the human world but committing acts thinking they are
above us or in part of a goal which however the humans will argue against, such
as the tale of Leda and the swan1.
Nikopol himself is one of them
objecting to this, especially as he falls in love with Jill and does not want
to be a willing participant, and that would be part of the narrative if fleshed
out that would make this a compelling film even if one some would
understandably feel uncomfortable to want to watch. Adding to the issue is that, improvising him a
leg from a subway train rail, Nikopol has an additional factor alongside the
fact Horus can control him on will that he cannot move said leg without the God
within him, so he is a trapped host having to argue against an entity doing
things he does not want. Immortal
would still be dealing with uncomfortable subject matter, which jars against
its stranger content and jokes, such as the Egyptian Gods up in the floating
pyramid playing Monopoly in one scene, but tackling the conflict between God
and human would be fascinating, with Jill the unfortunate stuck between this on
her road in fate.
However is it indeed uncomfortable,
despite Nikolai not being a willing subject, how much rape plays a part in this
as it does, even if mostly dealt with off-screen. It happens but the
repercussions are never dealt with. It was more the fact Nikolai and Jill begin
a romance soon into this, with a surprising amount of time "rape" and
"the rapist" in himself being in the dialogue, that we are in really
uncomfortable and undefendable content. In general, Jill is used in a way that,
come least a decade later, would not be defendable at all, in that she is just
a cipher. An idealised figure, played by a former model, who eventually to
become human loses all her memories, and has erased at opportunistic times when
involved with a botched kidnapping. Despite being a character to sell the film,
in her distinct pale white face and blue hued features, is honestly a prop,
even before you have to deal with the problematic content of sexual violence
that is explicitly here.
What makes this worse, and a much
more problematic film then when a film merely includes rape, is that Immortal's biggest problem is that none
of its plot points ultimately have a point, making those decisions in how to
handle gender politics and Jill worse. This very hastily wraps up with a bland
romance, deeply problematic in context, and not really using its enticing
points at all. There is no point to Central Park being frozen over barring as a
final location. Charlotte Rampling's
character has no real point at all, wasting a legendary actress, nor the CGI
character of a detective, a figure who, alongside a previous history with the
floating red sharks when one bit part of his face off, is seemingly to follow
the trajectory of being involved in the main plot, including finding about
Allgood's corruption, and contribute. He does not have a point, the red shark
is dispatched hastily, and Allgood and the entire Eugenic Corporation is never
really of importance. Even in mind this is based on stories in a world of Bilal's, this feels hurried and slight. It
of course feels a bad position for Bilal
to have left himself, when for the most part this film is an elaborate sci-fi
film, that the main plot involved the rather unsavoury content it does and
rushes all the interesting ideas after so much set-up.
It is fascinating, undoubtedly
so. Immortal however becomes less
than the sum of its parts by its finale, becoming far less interesting then the
film it was beginning. One really tasteless plot aspect does derail the film horrifically,
and it is weird to find a film which has so many strange ideas, and an
aesthetic most would call ill advised but I found compelling, only become
padding and ultimately resolve itself in the blandest way possible. Two of the
worst things you can be are predictable, and be tone deaf in objectionable content,
and Immortal's interesting features
are sadly lost within both.
======
1) Leda, an Aetolian princess,
who the Greek god Zeus turned into a swan to seduce or rape depending on the
telling of the myth; the blurring in that last part may come off as some as
problematic, which is entirely understandable, and is only upon reflection
that, becoming a subject depicted in countless paints of classical art alone,
making it still a contentious myth, least in reminding you how adult and dark
Greek mythology was in talking about complex concepts even with its Gods, that
has been interpreted in a variety of ways